Barnesville, Ohio

Every Scoop
Tells a Story

Small-batch, handcrafted ice cream made from premium ingredients — where every flavor is a journey and every visit feels like magic.

Scroll
The Collection

Signature Flavors

Each flavor is crafted in small batches with locally sourced ingredients and an unwavering commitment to quality.

Vanilla Bean - creamy handcrafted ice cream

Madagascar Vanilla

Classic

Real vanilla beans from Madagascar, slow-churned to a velvety, aromatic perfection that defines the gold standard.

Dark Chocolate - rich handcrafted ice cream

Belgian Dark Chocolate

Indulgent

Single-origin cacao, 72% dark chocolate folded into a rich, fudgy base — for those who take their chocolate seriously.

Wild Berry - fresh fruit ice cream

Wild Berry Swirl

Seasonal

A vibrant medley of blackberries, raspberries, and blueberries ribbed through a cream base — nature's candy, perfected.

Mint Chocolate Chip - refreshing ice cream

Fresh Mint Chip

Refreshing

Garden-fresh mint infused into a cool, creamy base studded with hand-chopped dark chocolate shards.

Salted Caramel - premium ice cream

Sea Salt Caramel

Signature

Butter-rich caramel swirled with Maldon sea salt — the perfect balance of sweet and savory that keeps customers coming back.

Pistachio - nutty premium ice cream

Bronte Pistachio

Premium

True Sicilian bronte pistachios, stone-ground and folded into a luxuriously smooth, pale-green cream.

Our rotating seasonal flavors are always changing — ask about today's special.

Fairyland Ice Cream shop interior with display cases
Handcrafted
Small-batch, made fresh daily with the finest ingredients.
Our Story

A Sweet Tradition
Rooted in Barnesville

Fairyland Ice Cream was born from a simple belief: that ice cream should be an experience, not just a treat. Nestled along Somerton Highway in the heart of Barnesville, our shop is a place where families gather, friends celebrate, and neighbors share something delightful.

Every batch is churned by hand in small quantities, using whole milk, farm-fresh eggs, and real fruit. No shortcuts, no artificial shortcuts — just the kind of honest, old-fashioned ice cream that makes people stop and savor the moment.

Whether you're visiting for our signature sea salt caramel or exploring a new seasonal creation, every scoop is made with the same care and attention we'd give our own family table.

The Experience

Why Fairyland Stands Apart

Small-Batch Crafted

Every batch is made by hand in limited quantities, ensuring peak freshness and flavor in every scoop.

Premium Ingredients

Real vanilla beans, farm-fresh cream, and locally sourced fruit — nothing artificial, nothing rushed.

Community Heart

More than a shop — a gathering place for Barnesville families, friends, and anyone who believes in good things.

Rotating Seasons

New flavors appear throughout the year, inspired by the seasons and the best ingredients each one offers.

Find Us

Come Visit Fairyland

Location

59345 Somerton Hwy
Barnesville, OH 43713

Call Us

Have questions or want to place a special order?

(740) 619-0016
Ready for Something Sweet?

Your Next Favorite
Flavor Awaits

Stop by Fairyland Ice Cream and discover why Barnesville keeps coming back for more.

Get in Touch

We'd Love to Hear from You

Have a question, special request, or just want to say hello? Drop us a message.

Is this your business?This is my business